Redken Extreme vs All Soft: Which Shampoo Wins for Damaged or Dry Hair?
Redken Extreme rebuilds protein-depleted, breaking strands with RCT Protein Complex; Redken All Soft drenches parched hair with argan oil for silkiness. One mends, one moisturizes—no overlap.
People grab the red bottle they spot first, then wonder why hair still snaps or feels greasy. The names sound interchangeable, so they assume “extreme softness” equals “extreme repair,” mixing goals and formulas in the shower.
Key Differences
Extreme uses proteins and amino acids to patch cortex cracks; pH 4.5–5.5. All Soft relies on argan oil and soy protein to seal cuticles; pH 5.0–6.0. Expect stiffer strands from Extreme, slip from All Soft.
Which One Should You Choose?
Choose Extreme if you see split ends or color damage; pair with a weekly mask. Pick All Soft if hair feels like straw but isn’t breaking; finish with leave-in oil. Rotate both if you’re both dry and damaged.
Can I use both shampoos in the same week?
Yes—alternate them. Extreme on wash day one, All Soft on wash day two to balance repair and moisture without overload.
Will All Soft weigh down fine hair?
It can. Use a dime-size amount, focus on ends, and rinse thoroughly to keep volume.